A development can stall for several reasons: costs overrun and the cost-to-complete test fails, the facility expires before completion, the builder runs into trouble, or the lender changes its appetite. In each case, every month on hold adds interest and risk.
First, diagnose the problem
- Overrun: the undrawn loan no longer covers the cost to complete.
- Expiry: the facility term ends before practical completion or sell-down.
- Builder: delays, disputes or a builder in financial difficulty.
- Lender: a change in the lender’s position, or a facility in default.
The answer depends on which of these it is, and often there is more than one.
The options
1. Top-up from the existing lender. Fastest where the lender is supportive, but often comes with tougher terms or more equity.
2. New developer equity. Simple, but it ties up capital that may be committed elsewhere.
3. A new facility sized to the remaining programme. A refinance replaces the existing senior debt, and sometimes the mezzanine, with a facility built around what it now costs to finish. This is often the cleanest solution.
4. Adding a tranche. Mezzanine or preferred equity can fund the shortfall behind the existing senior lender, subject to the senior lender’s consent.
What a refinancing lender will look at
- An independent cost to complete from a quantity surveyor
- The status and capacity of the builder
- An updated valuation
- The plan to repay: sell-down or a residual stock refinance
Real examples
- In our Inner West apartment transaction, the project was part way through delivery with an incumbent senior facility and expensive mezzanine. A single senior facility sized to the remaining programme retired the mezzanine.
- In our Moreton Bay industrial transaction, new construction funding reset the capital stack on a stalled build, with no further sponsor equity, and the warehouses were completed on programme.
The earlier the problem is addressed, the more options there are. Tell us where the project is up to.